Appeals court declines to fast track the Justice Department's bid to set aside 20,000 California ballots
Two of three 9th Circuit judges said the government had not given the trial court a chance to rule. A district judge takes up the case Tuesday, as Trump offers $1 million for voter fraud tips.
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday declined to rule on whether California officials may count about 20,000 mail ballots the Justice Department says belong to noncitizens, the Associated Press reported. Two of the three judges wrote that the government "failed to allow the district court adequate opportunity to consider" its request to sequester the ballots, according to the AP. The two sides meet again Tuesday before a federal district judge, leaving the government little time before the Nov. 3 election, the AP reported.
At rare weekend arguments on Sunday, Judge Mark Bennett, a Trump appointee, questioned whether the appeals court had jurisdiction before the lower court ruled, Judge Gabriel Sanchez, a Biden appointee, asked whether the government was commandeering the state, and Judge Patrick Bumatay, a Trump appointee, said everyone has an interest in ensuring only eligible citizens vote, the AP reported. Justice Department lawyer Matthew Donnelly argued that California was causing irreparable harm "by allowing noncitizens to vote in violation of their own state laws." Seth Waxman, representing Los Angeles County Clerk Dean Logan, said the federal list is unreliable and that checking the county's expected 2.75 million mail ballots for three minutes each would take about 140,000 hours, and a lawyer for Secretary of State Shirley Weber said the claim "has no basis in law or in fact," according to the AP.
On Monday, President Trump wrote on Truth Social that anyone "reporting Voter Fraud in the past Elections, or the upcoming 2026 Midterm Election, will be paid" $1,000,000 "upon the arrest and conviction of those that created the Fraud," FOX 5 DC reported, adding that he did not say where the money would come from. The Department of Homeland Security also announced that five noncitizens in Florida were charged last week with illegally voting in past elections, and Secretary Markwayne Mullin said noncitizen voting "steals the vote" of citizens, Fox News reported. Election experts from both parties say there is no evidence of widespread voter fraud, FOX 5 DC reported.
What is established
- The Justice Department sued California and Los Angeles County in mid October over about 20,000 ballots.
- The 9th Circuit panel was Bennett, Sanchez and Bumatay; two of the three declined to act before the district court.
- The district court hearing is set for Oct. 27.
- Trump's $1 million offer applies on arrest and conviction; the White House gave no further details.
What each side says
California is causing irreparable harm "by allowing noncitizens to vote in violation of their own state laws."
The government's claim "has no basis in law or in fact."
Anyone reporting voter fraud that leads to an arrest and conviction will be paid $1 million.
How it was covered
Left No reports
Center 3 reports
The Associated Press led with the appeals court sending the case back to the trial judge and the government's shrinking window, and detailed the judges' questions at Sunday's argument.
- Associated PressAppeals court declines to rule on federal bid to set aside California ballots of alleged noncitizens
- Associated PressTwo of three appeals judges appear skeptical of Justice Department push to hold California ballots from 20,000 flagged voters
- FOX 5 DCTrump offers $1 million reward for voter fraud tips that lead to convictions
Right 1 report
Fox News said judges questioned the case and paired it with DHS charges against noncitizen voters in Florida and Trump's reward offer; FOX 5 DC noted that experts from both parties see no evidence of widespread fraud.